A recent Wall Street Journal article critiques insurers for the recent use of computerized risk projection models to take global warming into account. Previously, insurers relied primarily on historical data to set rates. After the severe hurricanes in 2004, insurers started using new computer models to project natural catastrophes over the next several years (a
Uncategorized
Liability Policy for Professional Services Does Not Cover Alleged Violations Under False Claims Act.
Coverage for a suit involving false billing claims submitted in violation of the False Claims Act is generally not recognized under a liability policy. This was the result reached in a recent case decided by the Tenth Circuit. See Zurich Am. Ins. Co. v. O’Hara Regional Center for Rehabilitation, Nos. 06-1357 and…
Supreme Court Overturns Insurer’s Denial of Disability Benefits Based in Part on Conflict of Interest
The United States Supreme Court decided an insurance-related case last week involving the insurer’s potential conflict of interest in its dual role in administering and paying benefits under an ERISA plan. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Glenn, No. 06-923 (U.S. Supreme Ct. June 19, 2008). MetLife was the administrator and insurer of…
Endorsement Referencing Non-existent Standard is Not Enforceable
The Ninth Circuit recently decided that the insurer’s reliance upon a non-existent policy limit referenced by an endorsement was not supportable. See Ferguson v. Coregis Ins. Co., No. 06-35867 (9th Cir. June 3, 2008).
The policy issued to Coeur d-Alene School District by Coregis referred in several places to the…
Hawaii Federal District Court Remands Based On Undecided Coverage Issue
The Hawaii Federal District Court recently remanded a coverage case to allow the Hawaii state court to decide whether an exclusion in a professional liability policy was applicable. See Keown v. Tudor Ins. Co., 2008 U.S. Dis;t. LEXIS 42996 (D. Haw. May 30, 2008).
The insured was a realtor and…
Coverage Found for Insured Under Vendor’s Endorsement
In Sturla, Inc. v. Fireman’s Fund Ins. Co., 67 Haw. 203, 684 P.2d 960 (1984), the Hawai`i Supreme Court determined that the distributor of allegedly defective carpet was an insured under a Vendor’s Endorsement, but found there was no coverage based on exclusions in the policy. The opposite result was reached in…
Florida and Allstate Resolve Differences – For Now
In a prior post, we discussed Florida’s ongoing investigation of Allstate’s alleged collusion with other insurance companies to keep insurance rates artificially high. When Allstate failed to comply with a subpoena in January and testify about its property insurance business, it was suspended by Florida’s Office of Insurance Regulation.
Allstate’s…
California Court Finds Binding Arbitration Provision in Insurer’s Enrollment Application Unenforceable
Unlike California, Hawai`i law does not statutorily impose strict disclosure requirements when an insurance enrollment application mandates that disputes be resolved solely by arbitration. California courts, on the other hand, narrowly construe an insurer’s attempt to limit disputes to arbitration, as evidenced by the recent decision in Rodriguez v. Blue Cross of California…
Consider Flood Insurance as Another Hurricane Season Approaches
In a prior post, we noted that much of Honolulu has yet to be mapped by the Federal Emergency Management Agency for flood insurance purposes. This leaves neighborhoods unrated for flood insurance, resulting in high premiums even for areas not prone to floods.
An informative story appearing over the weekend in…
Seventh Circuit Narrows Scope of Coverage Under Umbrella Policies
Umbrella coverage typically provides two types of coverage: excess coverage and gap-filling coverage, which obligates the insurer to defend for any loss covered by the terms and conditions of the umbrella policy and not covered by the primary policy. In Dairy Road Partners v. Island Ins. Co., Ltd., 92 Hawai`i, 992 P.2d 93 …